Jim, interesting post. Having served as a fin serv professional for half my career, and a consultant to fin serv prof for half my career, I offer a few perspectives:
1) One can argue that the level of innovation and creativity in fin serv is TOO unbridled, think CDOs no one can really value, derivatives no one can size risk for, unanticipated black swan event implications, etc
2) If you have never worked IN a fin serv firm, you can't possibly understand the twisted regulatory environment or the true degree of limitations that actually exist. they aren't imagined. they are real. And the price of violating them is not small. That is a constraint imposed on fin serv firms from the outside, not within. Case and point: a fin serv firm could never do what Best Buy has done in social media. We could never enable 14k reps to tweet without limitation, nor could we administer twitter with open source software sitting on a server next to some engineer's desk. That does NOT mean we can't and should be aggressive and innovative in social media, but it requires us to rewrite every policy, and procedure we have to meet our regulatory, fiduciary, and security burdens. It takes a hearty soul to choose to take on the entire weight of their organization to drive this kind of change...is it no wonder few see the benefits?
3) Point #2 notwithstanding, I listen to agencies, consultants and vendors all day long, with lots of ideas about how we could improve, change, get better, innovate, etc. Most of which are either not grounded in the reality of the fin serv regulations, and as importantly, even if they are theoretically possible GROSSLY underestimate the amount of work it will take to bring it to fruition. The reality is this: Like a goalie in any sport, we are the last to credit for victory and the first to get blamed in defeat. And the closer you move to the risk management and legal parts of our organizations, the more that is true. Those folks have jobs to ensure our franchise does not go out of business and is meeting its duties -- they aren't rewarded for taking risk they are rewarded for eliminating it. You need to appeal to the risk takers, the business heads, but you still need to recognize and account for the huge challenge acceptable risk taking is -- and it will be even WORSE after the last few years of meltdowns caused by poor risk management.
If you want your fin serv clients to listen better, let me suggest you better understand the real -- not imagined -- constraints they operate in, and you will be able to package your ideas, help them see the path to possibility, and if you are persuasive, and your ideas compelling, you will find the champion you are looking for who can drive something through an organization.
Is Innovation Harder for Financial Services Pros? Tip: Questions are cool
Categories: Innovation Discussion Financial Services Future Trends New Products, Services, and Business Models Innovation Community Ideas
To raise your hand during class and ask a question between grades K-12 is a dangerous proposition for many kids. Asking means you dont know something. Not knowing something exposes weakness. Exposing weakness among kids can be socially lethal. So most kids clam up, resulting in less being asked and learned. The same happens in professional situations. Especially when bankers are involved.
We were all kids once; and many of us can relate to the fear of asking questions during our formative years. For me, there was nothing worse than calling attention to myself in front of all those kids. Asking a question implied to everyone in the classroom that I didn’t know something. I was sure that many kids were just waiting to pounce on my “not-knowingness” and label me uncool (or worse, stupid). So like many kids, I was content to clam up and try and figure stuff out myself. The funny thing is, I was then - and still am - an extrovert. I can only imagine how it must have felt for the shy, introverted kids.
When college came all that disappeared. Now I was among peers who actually wanted to learn. I can still remember the liberating feeling of being able to unleash my natural curiosity and [gasp] raise my hand and ask questions. Even better, I was able to connect with peers and professors who were so immersed in the desire to learn that we met often outside of the classroom to ask and answer each other’s questions. College taught me that, in reality, it’s the cool kids who ask questions, not the other way around.
That was over 30 years ago. Since then, I have unashamedly striven to ask and learn in any setting, during any challenge. It’s been decades since I felt uncool or uncomfortable when asking a question in a professional or social situation. And I have been the better for it.
A little more personal history: I worked over the years trying to help a broad variety of professionals innovate. Many of those professional are notorious know-it-alls. I’m talking about doctors/surgeons, attorneys, pilots, engineers, and psychologists, et al. All of them were challenging in their own ways, but none of them made me feel inferior when asking simple probing questions. And in my profession, curiosity and questions are the key to understanding and unearthing opportunities, the lifeblood of innovation. We call it celebrating our sense of wonder.
And then I began working with financial services professionals... Not just one brand, but a number of them. In each engagement I felt the old days of not wanting to ask questions envelope me like a suffocating wind. And was not alone. No one in my clients' organizations asked questions either. Roomfuls of financial services professionals and their associates would espouse information regarding regulations and reasons why things could never work. No one really asked questions or offered hope for change. Everyone just kept stating facts and tried to maintain the flow/status quo of the room — most of which were of the negative nature. They all seemed so afraid to swim upstream and “wonder.” As if there were some unspoken rule that curiosity is simply not allowed. Or worse, a fear, like during grades K-12, of being labeled stupid or unknowledgeable. A serious offense in financial services, I guess. How dare you not know everything?
Perhaps if these folk lightened up a bit and realized that they do not have all the answers (as evidenced by the events of the last 18 months), they might find that asking questions and wondering about “what-ifs” might be just the antidote for what ails them.
Hmmm, I wonder...
Have you seen the new Maddock Douglas homepage?
Follow Maddock Douglas on TwitterRead More In: Innovation Discussion Financial Services Future Trends New Products, Services, and Business Models Innovation Community Ideas
Thought leadership on innovation and the future of your industry from Maddock Douglas - The Agency of Innovation.
Click here to follow us on Twitter
Jamie: Thank you for your well thought out comments that clarify the regulations and risk within the financial services industry. I understand your challenges and sympathize with you.
I would like to respectfully note that the point of my blog was not to ask my financial service clients to "listen better" (though I would highly recommend they do so, especially as it pertains to their customers). The blogÂ's point was that financial services professionals should ask more questions versus their more common trait of stating problems and offering reasons "why not". One primary question that financial services professionals ought to begin asking is "how can we do that?" Moreover, I propose they continually ask that question even as the army of naysayers among them continually rises and offers myriad reasons how they cannot.
With complete and total respect to your position and history, I might suggest that your perspectives written above offer a very good example of my original point.
Thank you again for reading and commenting.
Jamie: I've reread your comments and would like to offer a little more clarification. You are correct, I am not an insider and do not fully understand the weight of the challenges you face every day. I do, though, work every day with those "hearty souls" you mention. Furthermore, I believe (and have seen) that within any industry -- financial services included -- there is an army of hearty souls who will follow a true innovation leader through incredible odds and challenges to achieve breakthrough solutions.
And so I apologize if I misread your comments. Perhaps rather than offering insurmountable challenges, you were stating that you are one of those hearty souls and/or leaders. If so, I "heartily" commend you. Good luck in your innovation endeavors.
Jamie and Jim,
Rock star posts. I really enjoyed reading them. Thank you.
My favorite saying: You can't read the label when you are sitting inside the jar. Unfortunately, the more we work on a particular challenge, the more our own expertise can get in our way. We wind up knowing so much about what is NOT possible, what the boss really wants, why Harry got fired, what the implications of failure really are, what has been tried in the past and failed...we know so much that it becomes very difficult to sponsor or create revolutionary change. Instead, we too often spend our time on evolutionary innovation that, because of our expertise is more practical and easier to do. Meanwhile, an upstart from outside the jar comes into our industry and changes the rules with new thinking. The next thing we know, we are stuck talking about "the good old days" and wondering how we didn't see the big whack in the head coming.
(Author's note: In high school I had a job moving furniture in a retail store. My boss would always say things like, "have WE moved the sofa", or "have WE filled the deliver truck". I remember thinking, 'yes WE have and OUR back is killing us'. So when I say WE, I really mean it. Every expert shares the same issue.)
I wrote on this topic in BW: http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/jul2008/ca20080729_220096.htm
So Jim, Jaimie ( and everyone), we all share the same challenge. The smarter we get about a topic, the harder it is to drive revolutionary change. Want to start a revolution? Find experts from outside your industry with enough practical knowledge to understand your challenges while still being able to help you see and drive the big, scary, game changing idea.
Now, which expert wants to come by the office and help us work on Maddock Douglas? It's getting a bit stuffy in this jar. (smiles guys). --Mike
I like how you made a "bond" between K-12 grades and the financial services. It reflects the "fear of getting caught" that you don`t know an answer to a question that is vital, simple, but the answer is hard to find. My ten year experience working at Office Cleaning Service made me think about this a lot, because we represent what clients want, so asking questions is a part of our job. "The lifeblood of innovation" must be present in any company and people should not be afraid to ask questions, they will always appear, but all of them have an answer.
View unverified member's comment - posted by Suzanne Twitchell


RSS