I can understand that most people don't think the government should take such a large role in overseeing the financial industry however, when looking at the current financial crisis I keep remembering the words of Alan Greenspan, who is a devout follower of the free market philosophy. Greenspan believes that our current situation came about from the greed of individuals, which he and the Fed did not account for. I have spent my entire career in the mortgage industry as well as retail banking, and I have a difficult time understanding derivatives. Most consumers do not understand what caused our financial crisis. Although, government regulation is not necessarily the answer, I do believe what we are seeing is the pendulum swinging to the opposite extreme of total deregulation, which inevitably happens. Consumers need to be better educated when buying financial products, and the financial industry does need some oversight to keep individual greed in check. The financial industry will profit greatly when consumers are employed, can intelligently borrow money and make smart financial decisions. The market will then dictate price and product features without the need for excessive regulation. The ultimate question is where is the ideal balance of consumer knowledge and financial industry regulation.
Who Should Fix The Financial Services Industry?
Categories: News, Rumors, Gossip, & Trends Culture Financial Services New Products, Services, and Business Models Innovation Community Ideas
While Obama and this administration are going to fairly extreme measures to intervene in the financial services and health insurance industries, the public may have a different view as to their ability to fix the situation.
What does “fixing” mean?
Assuming you're not a Schnauzer, the government’s definition is focused in the areas of derivatives, bailout, consumer protection and “too big to fail” issues. Getting better in these areas, which are all quite daunting, will help us “fix” the financial services experience for the American public.
But is the public in agreement that the government is the right place to have this happen?
According to a recent GfK Financial Services Study, 42% of Americans say they would like the government to take a diminished role in the financial services industry; not an insignificant figure by any means.
Then who is responsible?
If there is wide spread agreement that government is not going to provide the best, most innovative solution, it's left to private businesses and individuals to come up with the “big ideas”.
TIAA – CREF has taken some action in looking for ideas outside their company walls, specifically to “fix” the savings rate problem in the US. It's a wise idea, since they are trying to solve a problem and they are sitting in their own “jar”. Getting help from outside experts in parallel industries is a catalyst for innovation.
Where are the opportunities?
Under the umbrella of consumer protection, in particular, there is a significant demand for understanding. Not communication; understanding!
In fact a recent study conducted by Maddock Douglas shows that consumers are confused by language used by financial services and insurance companies. Despite that result 49% of consumers feel that they are EQUALLY as responsible as the financial services and insurance industries for learning to understand. Surprising, but very encouraging.
If one were to be thinking about innovation in financial services or insurance, I suggest stopping 3 things first:
- Stop assuming that the consumer understands what you are saying
- Stop assuming that the consumer will naturally behave irresponsibly
- Stop assuming you can get all the information you need by asking intermediaries.
Then start thinking about this:
- Get immersed in your target, deep insights through good research is the foundation for which the best ideas are formed.
- Bring outsiders in to help you figure it out. You can’t read the label when you are inside the jar.
- Follow through with excellent execution, keeping key stakeholders involved well beyond the idea generation phase.
By taking pause on the routine, and instilling new habits, different is bound to occur. While different isn’t always better, same is not an option!
Have you seen the new Maddock Douglas homepage?
Follow Maddock Douglas on Twitter
Read More In: News, Rumors, Gossip, & Trends Culture Financial Services New Products, Services, and Business Models Innovation Community Ideas
Thought leadership on innovation and the future of your industry from Maddock Douglas - The Agency of Innovation.
Click here to follow us on Twitter
Great points Julie. I believe that there is a great opportunity for innovation in understanding. Its not just about throwing the information out there and expecting consumers to "get it". There is a better way to make more consumers smart and therefor better customers for products and services.


RSS