create counter

Through the Lens of Insurance Agents: A Case For Asking Consumers Directly

There's a cool opportunity right in front of the eyes of the life insurance industry. The trouble is, their glasses are a little dirty.

In a business that is so distribution focused, or in hipper terms, “B to B”, it's not only convenient to ask producers and agencies for input before launching a new product, service or business model, it’s imperative. However many companies are stopping there. Sometimes it is because they don’t want to spend the money on consumer research when the agent is controlling the sale anyway, sometimes it is because there is a perceived threat in going to consumers directly, and sometimes it is because they just don’t think they will get a different answer.

What’s interesting is that the more the industry matures, the less validity there is to these arguments. Particularly in the case of millenials, (aka Gen Y), there is more and more disconnect between what the industry does and how it is relevant to these younger consumers.

The opportunity in front of us is innovating the language and manner in which we communicate.

A recent study by Maddock Douglas analyzed a number of commonly used insurance terminology and asked its respondents what they associated those words with. In some cases, they were asked to define what they mean. You may or may not be surprised at some of these finding. Did you know…?

…The word “protection”, a term used in almost every life insurance brochure or advertisement, is more often associated with birth control than it is insurance. This is true of Boomers, Gen X and Gen Y.

…For Gen Y, the word “policy” is associated with government or rules more than 60% of the time and insurance only 33% of the time.

…Gen Y also associates the word “agent” with the FBI more often than insurance.

…The word “disability” is more often associated with a handicap than it is about being unable to work.

…That insurance terms evoke the emotions of frustration, confusion, anxiety and boredom more than they do confidence or satisfaction.

But agents don’t necessarily agree with this. And it makes logical sense. Agents are very well informed, educated and experienced in these areas. They feel a sense of confidence all the time, and they can react in a more logical than emotional way.

In fact, at a recent LIMRA meeting, a study presented by Competiscan suggests that there is a big disconnect between the way that producers feel about company advertisements and literature and the way consumers do. Of 12 companies’ literature analyzed, consumers consistently gave lower scores than producers on the dimensions of clarity, reassurance, and likelihood of doing business. And in almost half of the companies surveyed, consumers and producers were on opposite sides of the spectrum with respect to emotional impact versus rational impact.

So what is the opportunity? Look at language and communication as “white space”. Think about doing some primary research and develop insights. Come up with some new ideas to help consumers hear your message in a way that makes them really get it logically, so they do not feel those negative emotions. Then, of course, turn it into new revenue streams for your company.

Anyone have any lens cleaner?

Have you seen the new Maddock Douglas homepage?

Follow Maddock Douglas on Twitter

Read More In: News, Rumors, Gossip, & Trends Culture Financial Services New Products, Services, and Business Models Innovation Community Ideas

Thought leadership on innovation and the future of your industry from Maddock Douglas - The Agency of Innovation.

Click here to follow us on Twitter



Discussion:    Add a Comment | Comments 1-12 of 12 | Latest Comment

July 14, 2010 8:02 PM

Your passion and enthusiasm excite me :-).

July 14, 2010 10:26 PM

Oh you aint seen nothin yet!!! ;)

July 15, 2010 10:51 PM

I don't have any lens cleaner, but I do have white board eraser. Maybe they are the same thing?

Frankly I'd heard you guys have a blog, and I got kind of freaked out. I need another blog or blog to follow like a hole to my head. Nevertheless, I was curious, so here I am, not entirely shocked by any of this. What you are essentially saying is that there is a new language which traditional insurance companies must adopt if they are to capture this growing young and healthy market? And if they don't create a need and a wish from this market, to these young people it would be the equivalent of listening to someone speak an ancient language from a bygone era that doesn't resonate with you. And you'd not be inclined to invest in the agent standing in front of you and delivering the presentation in (fill in the name of ancient language here). Don't make them bored (it's easy to do). Make them hurt so bad for it [insurance].

July 16, 2010 4:32 PM

Darn, I was hoping to shock you....(just kidding!)You said it right. Ancient language from a bygone era. It is more than the equivalent, that's actually what it is! These terms were developed hundreds of years ago when companies were in positions of total power over their customers. There was a "deference" to the institution. It was "all about the company". Today, no way. But they are still using the same words... For example "agent" means someone who represents the company. Today, consumers think of that professional as representing THEM! (or they should be). "Claim"...how arrogant is that? Like "you claim we are supposed to pay you a benefit? Prove it!". Or "policy", "It is our 'policy' to...." No wonder it doesn't resonate and they are bored!

July 16, 2010 10:07 PM

I agree.. and both 'agent' and 'claims' are not fun anymore! There's other ways to describe both though. What about being an agent of change? An advocate? Or instead of submitting a claim, a recap of services received? Language is a big reason why people have stopped listening, and there needs to be a friendlier and more engaging way to describe what it is that insurance companies offer.

Perhaps at the root of this is fear- fear that if the language is too friendly, averse attraction, over utilization etc. will occur, though in actuality more people would likely pursue basic insurance and many creative supplemental add ons if its language were more accessible and spoke to their lives. Earlier today - because I am insane- and am on break from what I usually do- I began writing down some possible words as well as a new plan idea that feels less like a 'policy' and more like a 'partnership.' But it's Friday night and Disney calls. Off to the niece...

July 16, 2010 11:32 PM

Oh I love these ideas! Who are you and where have you been all my life?

July 17, 2010 1:07 PM

Lol, thanks! Ah, maybe I will just be a troll and keep myself secret for awhile! ;) Rest assured a friendly troll and more of an innovator in the field of new media vs. insurance... but I see insurance as a big part of our national psyche and it's interesting to watch its industry (hopefully) change along with these uncertain times.

Though scary on many levels, massive change offers the perfect platform for reinvention. In regards to the government, I look at how the millions of federal stimulus dollars were applied- i.e. a few hundred minimum wage jobs created in Chicago at a cost of $72K per job of taxpayer's money!!- and wonder how the govt would handle a healthcare reform. The hippe in me hopes the govt can be effective in terms of adopting a plan, yet the pragmatist and capitalist part of me wonders what ideas are next up to bat from the insurance industry and how they'll 'find the pain' and offer consumers new ways to experience their products.

P.S. I dabble in comedy too!

July 18, 2010 9:57 AM

Wow, very cool. Its great to have a perspective from where you sit seeing the same problem we see. I think the "pain" answer lies in consumers really "getting" how it works. The black box of insurance has to be demystified. It is the way that people actually see the value they get. If they feel victim, they will constantly attack the system.

Comedy is a great outlet, right? I have not performed in a while but I would like to again soon....

July 18, 2010 10:42 AM

Totally agree... it really is a perception thing more on the part of Millenials and Ys vs. the Boomers who "get it" or the language of traditional insurance. Plus, the window of time you have to reach an ear is much tighter in a down economy. Being naturally nuerotic, and raised by nuerotic Boomers, I was raised to think that if you're not covered you will be doing something irresponsible, thus I've stayed at certain jobs longer than I should've in large part due to the health insurance.

Ah, yes, comedy is a great outlet! Though I do not perforn, I just love to write sketches and jokes and recently took a songwriting class. I am not a performer as I have stage fright and it takes so much time and practice, especially in standup circles, and very late nights. Tough to do with day jobs.

July 18, 2010 10:44 AM

Whoops. I spelled neurotic wrong. This blog needs spellcheck! :)
Oh, and I hope you find the time to do comedy again soon!

July 19, 2010 8:38 AM

Neurotic boomers are the best customers... :)

And stage fright can be managed. Just so you know...keep writing sketches though, it is a great way to build the confidence.

July 19, 2010 9:55 AM

I had a feeling they are the industy's best customers.:) Case in point, I'm on vacation, and my cat is with my neighbor having minor surgery on his ear today, but I was concerned and wondering if I should go back to Chicago for the surgery. My brother said that could be expensive to change flight and I told him I purchased trip insurance. He was not surprised. :)

Thanks, I will def not stop writing sketches and agree it builds confidance, though my preferred platform is paper. Blackouts are fun to write too. When my mom calls me, she prefaces whatever story she's about to tell me with "you need to write a sketch about this!"

Discussion:    Add a Comment | Back to Top | Comments 1-12 of 12 | Latest Comment

Add Your Reply

(will not be displayed)

Email me when comments are added to this thread

 
 

Please log in or register to participate in this community!

Log In

Remember

Not a member? Sign up!

Did you forget your password?

You can also log in using OpenID.

close this window
close this window